Own-damage claim rejected because the driver was 'drunk' — what the insurer has to show
Written for policyholders in India · Last reviewed 2026-11-17
In one insurer's private car policy, the drink-or-drugs exclusion is about loss suffered whilst the insured, or someone driving with the insured's knowledge and consent, is under the influence of intoxicating liquor or drugs — so ask the insurer what evidence shows that, at the time of the accident, and read it against the exact words of your own policy. The papers that matter are the ones that record the driver's condition: any breath-analyser or laboratory test, the hospital's notes and the police papers, and what each actually says rather than whether alcohol is mentioned. Answer the insurer's grievance officer in writing; if the insurer rejects the complaint, replies unsatisfactorily or does not reply within one month, the Insurance Ombudsman hears complaints about repudiated claims.
A rejection letter that says the driver was drunk, or 'under the influence', is pointing at an exclusion in the policy. Before you answer it, put two things side by side: the exact words of that exclusion in your own policy, and the evidence the insurer says it relied on. The gap between them is where a reply is built.
What the exclusion says, word by word
In one insurer's published private car policy, the own-damage section does not cover 'any accidental loss or damage suffered whilst the insured or any person driving the vehicle with the knowledge and consent of the insured is under the influence of intoxicating liquor or drugs'. Read as written, the clause has three parts, and the insurer's letter can be measured against each:[1]
- Who: The person must be the insured, or someone driving the vehicle with the insured's knowledge and consent.[1]
- When: The clause speaks of loss suffered 'whilst' that person is under the influence, so it is about the person's condition when the loss happened.[1]
- What: 'Under the influence of intoxicating liquor or drugs'. The example wording gives no number or test for this, so ask the insurer what standard it applied and where that standard comes from.[1]
The same insurer's customer information sheet puts it differently: it says the insurer will not cover expense arising from or traceable to an accident happening whilst you are under the influence. That sheet also says that where it and the policy document conflict, the policy document prevails. Other insurers' policies and two-wheeler policies may use their own words, so quote your own policy's clause, not a summary of it.[2]
Notice, too, what the example wording does not say. For war and related risks, its general exceptions add that 'the Insured shall prove' the loss was not connected with them; the intoxication exclusion has no such sentence. This page does not decide who must prove what in a dispute, which turns on the facts and on whoever hears it, but it is fair to ask the insurer to set out the evidence behind the exclusion it applied.[1]
The evidence that decides it
An allegation in a letter is not the same as a record. Collect every document that speaks to the driver's condition at the time of the accident, and read what each one actually says:
- A breath-analyser or laboratory test: Whether a test was done, when, by whom, and the result recorded. Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act is the provision the Act itself points to for driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, and the 2019 amending Act added the words 'or in any other test including a laboratory test' after 'breath analyser' in its clause (a). This page does not set out the limits or penalties in that section; check its current text.[3]
- Hospital or casualty notes: If the notes mention alcohol, check whether a test was done, who wrote the note, and whether it records a finding or a remark such as a history given by someone else. A note that mentions alcohol without a test result is not a test result.
- Police papers: The FIR, any challan or charge-sheet, and any accident or spot report. Check whether a drink-driving charge was actually made, what it rests on, and that the papers are about your driver and not someone in another vehicle.
- The insurer's investigation: If the letter relies on an investigator's or surveyor's report, ask for a copy. Asking for the documents the insurer relied on explains how.
- Your own evidence: Statements from passengers or witnesses, the time of the accident and of your call to the insurer, and anything that shows where the driver was and what they were doing beforehand.
The example policy requires the insured to give the insurer 'all such information and assistance as the Company shall require' after a loss. Answering its questions and handing over what you hold keeps you within that condition; it does not mean accepting the insurer's reading of the evidence.[1]
How to contest the rejection
Ask for the clause and the evidence.
If the letter names the ground but not the clause, or says the driver was under the influence without saying what shows it, write and ask for both. IRDAI's 2024 regulations require insurers to provide fair treatment at all times in processing the claim, and information at various stages of claim settlement.[4]
Match each document to the clause.
For each piece of the insurer's evidence, note whether it shows the person the clause names, at the time of the loss, under the influence, and where it falls short. An evidence map sets this out as a table.
Raise an IRDAI rule only where it fits.
IRDAI's 2024 master circular says a general insurer cannot repudiate a claim in full or in part where the breach of a warranty or condition is not relevant to the nature or circumstances of the loss. An exclusion is worded differently from a warranty or condition, and this page cannot confirm how that rule is applied to an intoxication exclusion; rely on it only if the letter treats the ground as a breach of a condition.[5]
Write to the grievance officer.
Answer the specific clause, attach your evidence and keep proof of sending. The insurer should resolve the complaint within 14 days and, if it does not accept it, give reasons that refer to the relevant terms and conditions of the policy. You can also register the complaint online on IRDAI's Bima Bharosa portal.[5]
Take it to the Insurance Ombudsman.
The Ombudsman hears complaints about any partial or total repudiation of claims by a general insurer, under rules that cover personal lines of insurance, meaning a policy taken in an individual capacity. You can file after your written complaint is rejected, gets no reply within one month, or gets a reply you are not satisfied with, and within one year of the rejection or decision, or of the end of one month after sending it if the insurer never replied.[6]
For the other grounds a motor rejection letter can give, and the clause behind each, see motor claim rejected.
Sources
The official documents this page relies on. Rules change: where it matters to your claim, check the current version at the source.
1. The New India Assurance Company Limited
Standard Form for Private Car Package Policy (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001)Accessed 2026-10-09 · Cited at: New India Assurance, Standard Form for Private Car Package Policy (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001), Section I exclusions, item (c), page 1; New India Assurance, Standard Form for Private Car Package Policy (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001), General Exceptions, item 6, page 3; New India Assurance, Standard Form for Private Car Package Policy (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001), Section III 'Personal Accident Cover for Owner-Driver', proviso B, page 2; New India Assurance, Standard Form for Private Car Package Policy (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001), Section III 'Personal Accident Cover for Owner-Driver', proviso B(b), page 2; New India Assurance, Standard Form for Private Car Package Policy (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001), Conditions, condition 1, page 3
2. The New India Assurance Company Limited
Private Car Package Policy – Customer Information Sheet (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001)Accessed 2026-10-09 · Cited at: New India Assurance, Private Car Package Policy Customer Information Sheet (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001), item 11 'Admissibility of Claim', point 5, page 8; New India Assurance, Private Car Package Policy Customer Information Sheet (UIN IRDAN190RP0042V01100001), legal disclaimer printed on each page
3. Ministry of Law and Justice (Legislative Department), Gazette of India
The Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 (No. 32 of 2019), Gazette of India Extraordinary, Part II Section 1, No. 51, 9 August 2019Dated 2019-08-09 · Accessed 2026-11-17 · Cited at: The Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 (No. 32 of 2019), Gazette of India Extraordinary, Part II Section 1, No. 51, 9 Aug 2019, section 68 (amendment of section 185), page 34; The Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 (No. 32 of 2019), Gazette of India Extraordinary, Part II Section 1, No. 51, 9 Aug 2019, section 51 (Chapter XI substituted), new section 150(2)(a)(ii), page 22; The Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 (No. 32 of 2019), Gazette of India Extraordinary, Part II Section 1, No. 51, 9 Aug 2019, section 51 (Chapter XI substituted), new section 150(2), page 22
4. Gazette of India (Extraordinary, Part III Sec 4), hosted by Department of Financial Services, Ministry of Finance
IRDAI (Protection of Policyholders' Interests, Operations and Allied Matters of Insurers) Regulations, 2024, F. No. IRDAI/Reg/11/205/2024, Hyderabad, 20 March 2024Accessed 2026-10-09 · Cited at: IRDAI (Protection of Policyholders' Interests, Operations and Allied Matters of Insurers) Regulations, 2024, regulation 23(2)-(3)
5. Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI)
Master Circular on Protection of Policyholders' Interests 2024, Ref IRDAI/PP&GR/CIR/MISC/117/9/2024, 5.09.2024 (English PDF, read on irdai.gov.in)Dated 2024-09-05 · Accessed 2026-11-16 · Cited at: IRDAI Master Circular on Protection of Policyholders' Interests (IRDAI/PP&GR/CIR/MISC/117/9/2024, 5 Sep 2024), Section 1, Part C (Retail General), V.4 para 6(a), printed page 46; IRDAI Master Circular on Protection of Policyholders' Interests (IRDAI/PP&GR/CIR/MISC/117/9/2024, 5 Sep 2024), Section 1, Part C (Retail General), VI.2(i), printed page 47; IRDAI Master Circular on Protection of Policyholders' Interests (IRDAI/PP&GR/CIR/MISC/117/9/2024, 5 Sep 2024), Section 1, Part C (Retail General), VI.1(ii), printed page 47 (the extracted text reads 'IRDAl's', an OCR artefact)
6. Council for Insurance Ombudsmen (hosting the Ministry of Finance rules)
The Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 [updated as on 9.11.2023] - consolidated copyDated 2023-11-09 · Accessed 2026-10-09 · Cited at: Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 (consolidated as amended to 9 Nov 2023), Rule 13(1)(b); Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 (consolidated as amended to 9 Nov 2023), Rule 3; Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 (consolidated as amended to 9 Nov 2023), Rule 4(1)(h); Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 (consolidated as amended to 9 Nov 2023), Rule 14(3)(a)(i)-(ii); Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 (consolidated as amended to 9 Nov 2023), Rule 14(3)(a)(iii); Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 (consolidated as amended to 9 Nov 2023), Rule 14(3)(b)(i)-(ii); Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017 (consolidated as amended to 9 Nov 2023), Rule 14(3)(b)(iii)
7. Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Gazette of India
S.O. 859(E), 25 February 2022: sections 50 to 57 and 93 of the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 brought into force from 1 April 2022Dated 2022-02-25 · Accessed 2026-11-17 · Cited at: S.O. 859(E), Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, 25 Feb 2022, English text, table of sections, page 2
ClaimAssure is an independent private platform. It is not an insurer, IRDAI, Bima Bharosa or the Insurance Ombudsman, it never files anything on your behalf, and it cannot promise any outcome. What it does is read your documents and show you what they say.
Read next
- Accident claim rejected because the car was sold or bought and the insurance was not transferredBought or sold a car and the claim was refused because the policy was not transferred? What section 157 says, and what buyer and seller should check.
- Car or bike insurance claim rejected — what the reason means and how to respondMotor claim rejected? Match the reason to the clause, test it against IRDAI's limits on rejections, then go to the insurer, Bima Bharosa or the Ombudsman.
- Motor claim rejected because the driver's licence was 'not valid' — what to checkCar or bike claim refused because the licence was 'not valid'? Check the driver's clause, the licence class and dates, and IRDAI's rule on unrelated breaches.
- Own damage or third-party claim — which applies, and where is each decided?Own-damage and third-party motor claims compared: where each is decided in India, and what to do if someone else claims against you after an accident.
- How to ask for the documents the insurer relied on — investigation reports, and where RTI fitsHow to ask an insurer for the investigation report and other papers behind a claim decision, and where an RTI request fits if the insurer is a public authority.
- How to match each document to the insurer's reason (an evidence map)Build an evidence map for a rejected or short-paid claim: one row per statement the insurer relies on, the document that answers it, and the gaps to fill.